I was wondering the other day about the origin of the phrase "pie in the sky." Here's what I found with a quick search online:
Pie in the Sky is defined by Dictionary.com as an empty wish or promise. Their definition entry offers the quote:
"To outlaw deficits... is pie in the sky"
Howard H. Baker, Jr.
I'll guess and say that the researchers for this site are using Baker's quote as an example, not an attribution. If it's intended as an attribution then they ought to refer to another of Houghton Mifflin's titles, The American Heritage® Dictionary of Idioms by Christine Ammer which traces the phrase back to 1911 when it was used in a rallying song by the International Workers of the World (or "Wobblies"):
"Work and pray, live on hay,
you'll get pie in the sky when you die."
![[image: Self-portrait, Holiday 2004, difc_gp_PC200063]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/difc_gp_PC200063.jpg)

![[image: Self-portraits, Holiday 2004 ids_PC19170]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/ids_PC19170.jpg)
![[image: Self-portraits, Holiday 2004 ids_PC19172]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/ids_PC19172.jpg)
![[image: most coveted gift at the Yankee gift swap]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/yankee_gift_swap.jpg)
![[image:Grand Avenue by Steve Breen]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/outsourced_santa.jpg)
![[image:xmasstackedreindeer by Dan Reynolds]](http://www.execnet.net/users/alan/blogs/archives/alanskew/xmasstackedreindeer_dan_reynolds.jpg)